Post by Spencer Adams on Jun 21, 2016 12:49:19 GMT -6
| Number | Wrestler | Reign | Date | Days Held | Location | Event | Defenses | Notes |
| 1. | Wentworth Updegraff Jr. | 1 | May 29, 2016 | 21 | Chicago, Illinois | Overload #2 |
| Inaugural Champion |
| 2. | Dustin Beaver | 1 | June 19, 2016 | 14 | Chicago, Illinois | Overload #4 |
| |
| 3. | Wentworth Updegraff Jr. | 2 | July 3, 2016 | 7 | Minneapolis, Minnesota | Overload #5 | None | Tied for Combined Record Reign: 2 Reigns |
| 4. | Jessica Buck | 1 | July 10, 2016 | 21 | Madison, Wisconsin | Overload #6 |
| |
| 5. | Chase Jackson | 1 | July 31, 2016 | 14 | Gainesville, Florida | #Beachmania | N/A | |
| 6. | Mandie Wheeler | 1 | August 14, 2016 | 21 | Des Moines, Iowa | Overload #7 |
| |
| 7. | Ryan Jones | 1 | September 4, 2016 | 7 | Salt Lake City, Utah | Overload #11 | N/A | |
| 8. | Kyle Kemp | 1 | September 11, 2016 | 14 | Portland, Oregon | Overload #12 |
| |
| 9. | Ryan Jones | 2 | September 18, 2016 | 50 | Albequerque, New Mexico | Overload #13 |
| Tied for Combined Record Holder: 2 Reigns Combined Record Reign: 57 Days |
| 10. | Kuno Kenji | 1 | November 7, 2016 | 21 | Biel, Germany | Overload #17 |
| |
| 11 | Teddy Sol | 1 | November 28, 2016 | 21 | New York City, New York | Civil War |
| |
| 12. | El Trebol Jr. | 1 | December 19, 2016 | 28 | Brooklyn, New York | Black Mass |
| |
| 13. | Teddy Sol | 2 | January 23, 2017 | 14 | Detroit, Michigan | Overload #24 |
| Tied for Combined Record Holder: 2 Reigns Combined Record Defenses: 4 Defenses |
| 14. | Demarcus Jordan | 1 | February 6, 2016 | 49 | Souix Falls, South Dakota | Overload #25 |
| |
| 15. | Erin Fausse | 1 | March 27, 2017 | 28 | North Little Rock, Arkansas | Overload #28 |
| |
| 16. | Damian Kaine | 1 | April 24, 2017 | 35 | London, England | Beyond |
| |
| 17. | Zombie McMorris | 1 | May 29, 2017 | 63 | St. Louis, Missouri | Lazarus |
| Single Record Reign: 63 Days Single Record Defenses: 6 Defenses |
| 18. | Kaz Mazy | 1 | July 31, 2017 | 21 | Los Angeles, California | Summermania |
| |
| 19. | Oblivion | 1 | August 21, 2017 | 7 | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Overload #40 | N/A | |
| 20. | Red Dragon | 1 | August 28, 2017 | 7 | Chicago, Illinois | Meltdown | N/A | |
| 21. | Sah'ta Thor | 1 | September 4, 2017 | 4+ | Shanghai, China | Overload #41 | N/A |
